The 1996 Everest Disaster – The Whole Story

The 1996 Everest Disaster occurred on May 10, 1996 when four groups of climbers set out to summit Mount Everest – one group led by Rob Hall of Adventure Consultants, another led by Scott Fischer of Mountain Madness, an expedition organized by the Indo-Tibetan Border Police and a Taiwanese expedition. The day would turn out to be the single most disastrous event in the mountain’s history, killing 8 and injuring others after an unexpected blizzard ravaged the climbers, trapping them high on the mountain. The year 2016 marked the 20th anniversary of the 1996 Everest Disaster.

The tragedy was a result of what some call Summit Fever and the over-commercialization of the mountain, which led to delays. At the heart of the disaster was a decision made by one of the team’s Sherpa guides, his leader’s ambitions and their head guide’s neglectful work ethic that resulted in a life-changing delay that killed 5 of the 8 mountaineers. This is what happened on that fateful Summit Bid Day, May 10, 1996.

1996 Everest Disaster Names You Need to Know

While every name involved with the 1996 Everest Disaster is important, there are a few names that require noting in order to understand the events of that day. Those are:

  • Rob Hall (Adventure Consultants Leader/Owner)
  • Scott Fischer (Mountain Madness Leader/Owner)
  • Lopsang Jangbu (Sherpa guide for Mountain Madness)
  • The legendary Ang Dorje (Sherpa guide for Adventure Consultants)
  • Sandy Hill-Pittman (socialite and press journalist for Mountain Madness)
  • Jon Krakauer (journalist for Adventure Consultants on assignment for Outside Magazine)
  • Anatoli Boukreev (head guide for Mountain Madness)

The Events that Caused the 1996 Everest Disaster

The Crowding and Overcommercialization of Everest

According to Jon Krakauer’s version of the events, Mount Everest was crowded that spring, with expeditions from Taiwan, America, New Zealand, South Africa, and more. This is the first contributing factor to the tragedy. Second, the commercialization of Everest was noted to be a contributing factor, as competition to reach the summit increased with the pursuit of publicity. Both Adventure Consultants (AC) and Mountain Madness (MM) had two public figures present that season, Krakauer on assignment for Outside Magazine and Sandy Hill-Pittman, a socialite and journalist on Scott Fischer’s team.

The Fixed Ropes Are Not Set

A third contributing factor came with leaders Rob Hall and Scott Fischer deciding to work together to reach the summit on the same bid day. In doing so, both decided that one sherpa from each team would be designated to set fixed ropes leading to the summit. Chosen were Lopsang Jangbu of MM and Ang Dorje of AC.

However, on Summit Day, Lopsang Jangbu did not begin ascending before the team to assist Dorje with the ropes. Instead, he short-roped Sandy Pittman for the ascent, causing him to climb at a slow rate. Consequently, Ang Dorje refused to work alone. This was the major factor that Krakauer hints about in his book as being the catalyst to the proceeding catastrophe.

Later, Krakauer would interview Jangbu to ask him why he veered from the designated plan. He stated that, at first, he thought he had short-roped another climber who was lagging, and when he realized it was Sandy an hour later, he unclipped her. Later, he would change his story to say that Pittman reaching the summit was important to Fischer, as it would come with publicity and increased clientele.

Because she was not a significantly experienced climber, he thought short-roping her would increase her chances of reaching the top if he escorted her at a steady rate past the others. Jangbu told Krakauer that Fischer did not ask him to do so. Both Jangbu and Pittman stated that the short-roping did not last for more than an hour. But various other climbers attested to it lasting up to five hours.

Ultimately, as a result of the fixed ropes not being set, a bottleneck of climbers accumulated towards the summit, slowing everyone down. A turn-around time of 2:00 p.m. had been established. Still, some climbers were delayed because of the bottleneck, including Krakauer who had been ahead of the team from the start. Eventually, Anatoli Boukreev and Neal Beidleman assumed the responsibility of the ropes, and it took quite a while to set them.

Affiliate:

Climbers Continue Past the Turnaround Time

By this time, a storm had been brewing below them. Instead of turning clients around, because the guides knew they would not reach the summit before 2:00 p.m., Rob Hall and Scott Fischer’s guides (who were now leading their team without Fischer) chose to keep going. This was the fourth contributing factor.

Those ahead of the line summited (Krakauer was one of them). They turned around and began their descent, passing Rob Hall and the rest of the teams who were still on their way up. These descending climbers headed right into the storm.

Anatoli Boukreev Ascends Alone, Leaving Team Behind

Here, we meet the fifth contributing factor. Boukreev decided to make an early ascent. Since working for Scott Fischer, Boukreev had a habit of climbing ahead of clients and reaching the summit on his own. His reasoning for this was that he felt guides were not there to babysit climbers, and he felt that those who chose to go to the mountain should be able to take care of themselves.

In fact, Fischer and Boukreev got into a few arguments over the matter. On May 10, 1996, the situation was no different. Boukreev ascended the mountain alone and descended alone, not guiding any of the climbers up or down, even though he was the “head guide.”

On this day, after reaching the summit, he quickly descended before the MM team made it to the top, leaving them to descend slowly with little help. Ideally, if Boukreev had descended with the team and been carrying supplemental oxygen, he may have been able to assist them in descending much faster, possibly making it to camp before the storm erupted into a fierce rage.

Later, Boukreev would state that he descended because he wanted to be fresh and reach camp so he could assist in a rescue if needed in case something happened to the descending climbers. Though this information made Boukreev seem like an incompetent leader, we do have to give him praise for this. In the end, he was one of the only climbers in Camp 4 that had enough energy to save anyone stuck in the storm.

The Storm Traps Climbers During 1996 Everest Disaster

Close to 4:00 p.m., client Doug Hansen finally reached the summit with the assistance of Rob Hall, who remained behind to see his bid through. Shortly after, Hansen collapsed and Hall refused to leave him, setting the stage for a tragedy. Both were trapped on the South Summit by the storm. Below, members of the AC and MM team were also trapped by the storm 600 ft. from the nearest camp.

These climbers had managed to get this far because of the almost superhuman dedication shown by MM guide Neal Beidleman, who literally helped drag 5 climbers down the South Ridge as far as he could. Beidleman guided Sandy Pittman, Charlotte Fox and Tim Madsen from the MM team. He also dragged Yasuko Namba and Beck Weathers from the AC team down as far as he could, literally dragging everyone if they stopped, all while battling a raging storm. He then stopped and left the climbers in a relatively safe location and headed for Camp 4 in search of help.

As the storm raged on, Boukreev would attempt to rescue the lower lying climbers, saving Sandy Pittman, Charlotte Fox and Tim Madsen – all members of his MM team. AC climbers Yasuko Namba and Beck Weathers were determined to be “un-savable” and were left behind. Beck Weathers later recounts this in his book Left for Dead.

8 Climbers Die During the 1996 Everest Disaster

Over the course of the night, Doug Hansen would die. Rob Hall would tragically die on the South Summit the next day. His guide, Andy Harris, was stricken with hypoxia, and he would also perish.

Rob Hall was the last of all the climbers to die, surviving two nights on the South Summit and part of a third day. He was patched to his wife, who was heavily pregnant, via satellite phone and said his goodbyes. His last words to her were heartbreaking:

“Sleep well my sweetheart. Please don’t worry too much.”

The bodies of Andy Harris and Doug Hansen were never found. The body of Scott Fischer was tied to the mountain by his Sherpa, Lopsang Jangbu, and later recovered. The body of Rob Hall remained on the South Summit for a short time until it fell 12,000 ft. to the base of the mountain.

In 1997, Anatoli Boukreev found Yasuko Namba’s body and erected a cairn to protect her from scavenging birds. Later that same year, her husband would fund an expedition to bring her body down from the mountain.

Beck Weathers miraculously survived and would later go on to write “Left for Dead,” the tale of how he was abandoned on the mountain three times and left for dead, ultimately having to save himself. His wife, Peach, went down in history as having organized a historic rescue mission that saw the first-ever helicopter land higher than Camp 1 that saved his life. He lost his nose, all five fingers on his left hand and half of his right arm to frostbite.

screen-shot-2017-01-10-at-12-58-57-am

The Adventure Consultants team. The members who perished are: Bottom Row: Yasuko Namba (1st on the right), Rob Hall (3rd from right), Andy Harris (4th from right and next to Rob Hall), and Doug Hansen (Last on left). Third from the right in the top row is Beck Weathers and third from the left on the bottom row is Jon Krakauer.

Jon Krakauer went on to detail the events in his book “Into Thin Air,” and Anatoli Boukreev did the same in his Bestseller, “The Climb.”

Other climbers also died during the storm, Tsewang Samanla, Dorje Morup and Tsewang Paljor. The last, Tsewang Paljor, sought refuge in a small cave and would later be known as “Green Boots” for two decades by climbers who used his body as a trail marker. The name was in regards to a pair of lime green climbing boots Paljor was wearing when he died.

Almost 10 years later to the day, on May 15, 2006, English mountaineer David Sharp would also die in the same cave after attempting to summit the mountain alone and at night. All were climbing the North Route.

800px-green-boots

The body of Tsewang Paljor, later to be known as “Green Boots.” His body has since been moved. | Image Credit Maxwelljo40 Wikipedia | License

Due accreditation was given to Boukreev, noting him a hero for braving the storm to save the clients; credit was also given to Neal Beidleman. Neal Beidleman singlehandedly dragged 3 members of his team and 2 members of the AC down the mountain until he couldn’t go any further. It was also detailed how Boukreev bravely came through and saved 3 of those 5.

The event has stayed with mountaineers for two decades. That is a lifetime ago, but in Mountaineering history, everything is like it happened yesterday, especially when today could be your last. All things must be remembered as if they occurred yesterday.

In memory of those who perished on May 10-12, 1996 on Mount Everest. 

Films & Television Programs of Interest 

  • Everest. Dir. Baltasar Kormákur. Perf. Jason Clarke, Josh Brolin. Universal Pictures, 2015. Film.
  • Frontline: Storm Over Everest. Dir. David Breashears. Perf. Neal Beidleman, David Breashears, Guy Cotter. PBS, 2008. DVD.
  • Everest: IMAX. Dir. David Breashears, Greg MacGillivray, and Stephen Judson. Perf. Liam Neeson, Ed Viesturs, David Breashears. Miramax, 1998. DVD.
  • Everest: The Death Zone. Dir. David Breashears and Liesl Clark. Perf. Jodie Foster, David Breashears, David Carter. Nova, 1998. DVD. On YouTube Pt1. Pt2. Pt.3 Pt.4
  • Into Thin Air: Death on Everest. Dir. Robert Markowitz. Perf. Christopher MacDonald, Peter Horton, Richard Jenkins. Columbia TriStar Television, 1997. DVD.
  • Johnson, Gareth, dir. “Into the Death Zone.” Seconds From Disaster. 26 Nov. 2012. Television.
  • Also see our article: Wexcomb, Catherine “1996 Everest Disaster Documentaries on YouTubeBase Camp Magazine, Feb. 2018

All movies and episodes have been linked to YouTube where available. We encourage you to purchase or rent the DVDs if possible.

Articles of Interest

Notice of Deaths During & After 1996 Expedition


Free 2-Day Shipping on Orders over $49!


Sign Up For Elevated Rewards Membership at MountainHardwear.com.

Affiliate links help support this site and its hard-working staff.

Advertisements

29 responses to “The 1996 Everest Disaster – The Whole Story

  1. Pingback: Book Analysis: “Into Thin Air” by Jon Krakauer | Base Camp Magazine·

  2. Pingback: What Are the Seven Summits? | Base Camp Magazine·

  3. Pingback: The Seven Summits According to Messner | Base Camp Magazine·

  4. Pingback: Short Definitions for High-Altitude Sicknesses | Base Camp Magazine·

  5. Pingback: Man Nearly Killed on Everest for Dodging $11,000 Permit. | Base Camp Magazine·

  6. Pingback: Everest2017 Marks 21st Anniversary of the 1996 Everest Disaster | Base Camp Magazine·

  7. Pingback: Is the Hillary Step Gone? Everest2017 | Base Camp Magazine·

  8. Pingback: 4 Incredible Sherpa Climbers (Still Alive) | Base Camp Magazine·

  9. Pingback: Dealing With Post-Expedition Depression | Base Camp Magazine·

  10. Pingback: Dealing With Post-Expedition Depression | Base Camp Magazine·

  11. Pingback: The Wait is Over, Fredrik Sträng Attempts K2 Summit Today | Base Camp Magazine·

  12. Pingback: Editor’s Note: Get to Know the Editor of BCM | Base Camp Magazine·

  13. Pingback: Vanessa O’Brien Thinks the Nanga Parbat Rescue Could Have Climbed Higher to Save Tomasz Mackiewicz | Base Camp Magazine·

  14. Pingback: The 2008 K2 Tragedy | Base Camp Magazine·

  15. Pingback: 1996 Everest Disaster Documentaries on YouTube | Base Camp Magazine·

  16. Pingback: Book Analysis: “The Climb” by Anatoli Boukreev | Base Camp Magazine·

  17. An interesting discussion is worth comment. There’s no doubt that that you ought to
    write more on this issue, it may not be a taboo subject but generally people don’t discuss such topics.
    To the next! Cheers!!

    Liked by 1 person

  18. Pingback: K2 Remains Unconquered in Winter | Base Camp Magazine·

  19. Pingback: Experiencing Mendoza with Adventure Consultants – C. Leger | Writer & Editor·

  20. Pingback: Charlotte Fox Survivor of 1996 Everest Disaster Dies | Base Camp Magazine·

  21. Pingback: Charlotte Fox Survivor of 1996 Everest Disaster Dies | Base Camp Magazine·

  22. I’m surprised that you are calling the storm “unexpected”. Graham Ratcliffe, in his book A Day To Die For provided clear and unequivocal evidence that: 1) the storm was forecast, and 2) Rob and Scott both knew about it. The basecamp was receiving high altitude weather reports from two sources on a daily basis. Part of the forecast was for increasing winds starting on May 8th and peaking at 100+ km/hr on the 11th. If anything was unexpected, it was the lull on the 10th. I would suggest reading his book and revising your article accordingly. Lou Kasische discussed in his book how Anatoli questioned the weather window twice an how uncomfortable many climbers on both the AC and MM teams were uncomfortable with the weather “high up”. Rob discussed the weather reports with his team in general terms, so Krakauer knew.

    While Ratcliffe was writing his book, he sent a regstered letter to Krakauer asking for is input. Krakauer never responded. A PBS website was posting regular updates and the posts mentioned weather forecasts (I found that page in 2016. The info might still be there). Why did Krakauer leave this information out of his account?

    According to Ratcliffe, David Breshears knew about the forecasts because his team was one of the ones receiving the forecasts, but he still talks about a “rogue storm”. Why?

    This is important information about the event. Why is everyone ignoring it?

    Like

  23. Pingback: The Seven Summits According to Messner | Base Camp Magazine·

  24. Pingback: What are Sherpa Guides? | Base Camp Magazine·

  25. Pingback: The Seven Summits According to Richard Bass | Base Camp Magazine·

  26. Pingback: Editor’s Note: Relationships and Mountaineering: Why You Shun It but Shouldn’t | Base Camp Magazine·

  27. Pingback: Everest2017 Marks 21st Anniversary of the 1996 Everest Disaster | Base Camp Magazine·

  28. Pingback: Mount Everest: Why do hundreds of mountaineers risk life and limb to reach the top of the world every year? – Colleen Braganza·

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s